Paid ads were once among the most reliable tools in a marketer's arsenal. Spend budget, reach audiences, collect performance data, A/B test, optimize, and repeat. There was clarity about how much it took to generate a given return. So, naturally, paid advertising accounted for a large share of most brands' marketing budgets.
Then marketers got very good at making paid ads efficient. Nearly every aspect of the production and optimization process became fast and affordable for virtually any brand to run efficient, polished campaigns.
That's great— until it isn't.
When everyone can produce a high-performing ad, ads stop being an effective differentiator. Many just add to the noise and make consumers zone out, rather than stand out. CPCs start rising, and they don’t slow.
Paid ads were once no-brainers for two reasons, not one. The first was reach. The second, and arguably more important one, was predictability. Spend X and get Y impressions back. Watch your cost-per-click. Marketers could build reliable feedback loops between budget and outcome, making paid media one of the few channels where ROI felt genuinely measurable and controllable.
That clarity is eroding on both fronts now, though the numbers still make paid ads seem like a good investment: HubSpot's State of Marketing Report 2025 ranks paid social as the #2 ROI driver for both B2B and B2C brands, and over 75% of marketers plan to increase or maintain their search and display investment in 2026. Ad spending in digital audio alone increased more than 10% from the year prior. Brands are still spending.
But the clean spend-to-outcome ratios that once made paid media so manageable have grown murkier.
Platform algorithm changes, signal loss due to privacy updates, and increasingly crowded ad inventory make it harder to close the predictable feedback loop. And 2025 data from Taboola and Qualtrics corroborates that 75% of performance marketers are already seeing diminishing returns on social media ad spend.
So brands are spending more, optimizing harder, and getting less signal back. Their real problem is strategic. When paid ads were harder to execute, doing them well was a competitive edge. Now that the playing field is level, running efficient ads is table stakes, where you’re kept in the game, but not distinguishable.
If a lean, optimized paid ads budget no longer sets your brand apart, what does?
Increasingly, the answer is brand marketing.
Specifically, the kind that builds trust and authority over time rather than chasing short-term conversions. Brand marketing channels are becoming what sets one company apart from another, with earned media placements, thought leadership, original research, and content that position a brand as a genuine voice in its industry.
This mirrors a broader shift in how brands are investing in audience relationships. Events and activations spending, for instance, has grown significantly as companies look to create physical touchpoints where consumers can interact with and experience products directly.
The underlying logic is the same: when digital noise is everywhere, trust and depth become scarcer and more valuable.
The paid ads problem has parallels to content marketing. A lot of branded content follows the same formula to optimize for search and AI discoverability: use an H2 or H3 posed as a question, provide a concise answer in the opening sentence, and keep the formatting clean — at a glance, it looks exactly like everything else. When every brand sounds alike, content becomes bland, leaving no reason for an algorithm, a human, or an AI to surface yours over a competitor's.
What helps is genuine depth that requires more thought and resources. Large language models prioritize content with first-party data, original research, case studies, and tactical takeaways that require real resources to produce. Since AI synthesizes consensus, producing content that reflects that gives your brand no advantage in how it's retrieved or cited.
The brands that win on content are producing work that's worth citing.
The strongest brand marketing strategy right now isn't louder ads or more content. It's becoming an authentically credible, cited source in your industry.
That means developing original editorial content grounded in proprietary data and real expertise. It means earning media placements that signal authority to both human readers and the AI systems increasingly mediating information discovery. And it means treating content not as a conversion funnel, but as a long-term investment in your brand's reputation as a trustworthy voice.
Brands that do this well become visible because they're credible. And credibility compounds with earned media in ways that ad spend cannot.
Paid ads still have a role in the marketer’s playbook. They're efficient at driving awareness and short-term performance when the creative is strong, and the targeting is spot-on. But if your marketing strategy leans too heavily on paid media as the main way to distinguish the brand, you're competing in a field where the advantages are shrinking and where the feedback loops that once made that spending feel safe and measurable are harder to trust.
The opportunity for marketers lies in building trusted brands with earned placements, original research, editorial content that says something your competitors can't, and offers a consistent POV that makes your brand worth seeking out — not just worth a click.
See how Stacker can help you make your brand investments effective again by leveraging your editorial into earned reach.
Benjamin Chipman is a GenZ brand and content marketer at the intersection of media and storytelling. Informed by his experiences across the creator economy and the TODAY Show, Benjamin has a unique perspective about where traditional and new media converge. Passionate about where brands come together with culture and community, he brings this to all things brand and content at Stacker.
Featured Image Credit: Photo Illustration by Stacker // Canva