#50. Lake Forest College
- Location: Lake Forest, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 58%
- Net price: $26,968
- SAT range: 1020-1240
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $50,900
- Overall rank: #239

When you look at a ranking of the best colleges in America, you'll notice that the top schools tend to be on the East or West Coast. For example, of the top 10 schools on U.S. News & World Report's 2027 Best Colleges in America, six are on the East Coast, two are on the West Coast, and the South can only claim one, while the Midwest has two. And many of these schools are hugely competitive, making admission an academic achievement. Columbia University, Yale University, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology each accepted less than 5% of applicants in 2026, according to data obtained by Forbes.
However, times may be changing. Forbes' annual list of New Ivies—elite schools that fall outside of the traditional Ivy League—put five Midwest universities in the top 10 of both public and private colleges in the United States. Schools like Northwestern University in Illinois, Purdue University, and the University of Notre Dame in Indiana are highly selective and provide a rigorous education for students.
With the Fall 2026 semester now underway, rigorous education has picked back up at college campuses across the Midwest. To showcase the institutions in the area, Stacker used Niche's 2023 Best Colleges in America list to identify the best 50 schools in the Midwest. Niche's rankings use data from the Department of Education on academics, admissions, student life, and reviews from current students and alums. Only colleges in Midwestern states—Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin—were included.
Click through our list to find which colleges made the cut, and if the top spot went to a big-name football school, a land-grant institution, or a bucolic liberal arts campus.
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs that pay over $150k
- Location: Lake Forest, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 58%
- Net price: $26,968
- SAT range: 1020-1240
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $50,900
- Overall rank: #239
- Location: St. Peter, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 71%
- Net price: $26,701
- SAT range: 1080-1340
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $51,700
- Overall rank: #237
- Location: Chicago, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 98%
- Net price: $18,790
- SAT range: 990-1200
- Median earnings six years after graduation: No data available
- Overall rank: #236
- Location: Holland, Michigan
- Acceptance rate: 78%
- Net price: $30,320
- SAT range: 1130-1330
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $46,200
- Overall rank: #235
- Location: Athens, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 87%
- Net price: $23,307
- SAT range: 1050-1250
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $40,500
- Overall rank: #234
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs in education
- Location: Chicago, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 73%
- Net price: $12,614
- SAT range: 1030-1250
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $54,300
- Overall rank: #229
- Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
- Acceptance rate: 82%
- Net price: $34,732
- SAT range: 1160-1340
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $62,600
- Overall rank: #228
- Location: Bloomington, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 57%
- Net price: $32,545
- SAT range: 1100-1300
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $59,100
- Overall rank: #222
- Location: Chicago, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 70%
- Net price: $33,319
- SAT range: 1050-1260
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $53,300
- Overall rank: #213
- Location: Wooster, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 65%
- Net price: $27,923
- SAT range: 1150-1380
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $46,300
- Overall rank: #210
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs that don't require a college degree
- Location: Oberlin, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 35%
- Net price: $42,745
- SAT range: 1270-1360
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $40,800
- Overall rank: #209
- Location: Saint Paul, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 87%
- Net price: $31,799
- SAT range: 1130-1340
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $56,800
- Overall rank: #203
- Location: Cedarville, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 59%
- Net price: $24,965
- SAT range: 1110-1350
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $41,300
- Overall rank: #199
- Location: Appleton, Wisconsin
- Acceptance rate: 69%
- Net price: $26,594
- SAT range: 1190-1410
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $44,100
- Overall rank: #198
- Location: Point Lookout, Missouri
- Acceptance rate: 14%
- Net price: $7,505
- SAT range: 1090-1240
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $32,500
- Overall rank: #194
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs that pay over $75k
- Location: Rapid City, South Dakota
- Acceptance rate: 86%
- Net price: $19,799
- SAT range: 1150-1350
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $56,500
- Overall rank: #188
- Location: Manhattan, Kansas
- Acceptance rate: 95%
- Net price: $18,494
- SAT range: —
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $45,600
- Overall rank: #185
- Location: Des Moines, Iowa
- Acceptance rate: 68%
- Net price: $30,321
- SAT range: 1110-1340
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $58,300
- Overall rank: #182
- Location: Berrien Springs, Michigan
- Acceptance rate: 49%
- Net price: $22,850
- SAT range: 1030-1380
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $45,200
- Overall rank: #180
- Location: Greencastle, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 68%
- Net price: $30,183
- SAT range: 1110-1360
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $54,000
- Overall rank: #177
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs in health care
- Location: Columbia, Missouri
- Acceptance rate: 82%
- Net price: $16,930
- SAT range: 1110-1320
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $48,300
- Overall rank: #156
- Location: Lawrence, Kansas
- Acceptance rate: 91%
- Net price: $20,054
- SAT range: 1070-1320
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $48,800
- Overall rank: #155
- Location: Crawfordsville, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 63%
- Net price: $24,412
- SAT range: 1120-1320
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $56,300
- Overall rank: #153
- Location: Dayton, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 81%
- Net price: $32,768
- SAT range: 1080-1300
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $55,100
- Overall rank: #150
- Location: Granville, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 28%
- Net price: $39,808
- SAT range: 1220-1430
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $48,800
- Overall rank: #142
You may also like: These 25 colleges produce the highest-paid graduates, according to federal data
- Location: Northfield, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 51%
- Net price: $27,838
- SAT range: 1150-1390
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $50,400
- Overall rank: #140
- Location: Ames, Iowa
- Acceptance rate: 88%
- Net price: $16,105
- SAT range: 1010-1310
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $50,700
- Overall rank: #133
- Location: St. Louis, Missouri
- Acceptance rate: 56%
- Net price: $27,872
- SAT range: 1160-1370
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $56,500
- Overall rank: #132
- Location: Cincinnati, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 76%
- Net price: $22,767
- SAT range: 1120-1330
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $42,300
- Overall rank: #131
- Location: Wheaton, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 87%
- Net price: $27,474
- SAT range: 1210-1450
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $48,400
- Overall rank: #125
You may also like: 30 best colleges on the East Coast
- Location: Iowa City, Iowa
- Acceptance rate: 84%
- Net price: $17,452
- SAT range: 1110-1310
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $51,900
- Overall rank: #123
- Location: Houghton, Michigan
- Acceptance rate: 70%
- Net price: $17,356
- SAT range: 1160-1350
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $66,400
- Overall rank: #114
- Location: Bloomington, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 80%
- Net price: $13,191
- SAT range: 1120-1350
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $47,700
- Overall rank: #113
- Location: Terre Haute, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 77%
- Net price: $43,606
- SAT range: 1260-1460
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $80,900
- Overall rank: #109
- Location: East Lansing, Michigan
- Acceptance rate: 76%
- Net price: $16,655
- SAT range: 1100-1300
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $53,600
- Overall rank: #103
You may also like: The top 25 party schools in America, ranked by students
- Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 70%
- Net price: $17,729
- SAT range: 1240-1460
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $51,900
- Overall rank: #92
- Location: Gambier, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 37%
- Net price: $40,862
- SAT range: 1280-1460
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $48,700
- Overall rank: #87
- Location: Saint Paul, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 39%
- Net price: $35,589
- SAT range: 1280-1450
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $47,600
- Overall rank: #84
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 68%
- Net price: $18,884
- SAT range: 1210-1430
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $46,100
- Overall rank: #80
- Location: West Lafayette, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 67%
- Net price: $12,294
- SAT range: 1170-1420
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $55,100
- Overall rank: #79
You may also like: Fastest-growing jobs in STEM
- Location: Northfield, Minnesota
- Acceptance rate: 21%
- Net price: $30,843
- SAT range: 1330-1520
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $54,200
- Overall rank: #77
- Location: Grinnell, Iowa
- Acceptance rate: 19%
- Net price: $32,091
- SAT range: 1370-1540
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $49,100
- Overall rank: #73
- Location: Cleveland, Ohio
- Acceptance rate: 30%
- Net price: $36,002
- SAT range: 1340-1520
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $74,600
- Overall rank: #65
- Location: Urbana, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 63%
- Net price: $13,517
- SAT range: 1200-1460
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $61,500
- Overall rank: #59
- Location: Madison, Wisconsin
- Acceptance rate: 57%
- Net price: $14,030
- SAT range: 1260-1460
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $56,200
- Overall rank: #53
You may also like: The Most Educated Cities in America in 2026
- Location: Ann Arbor, Michigan
- Acceptance rate: 26%
- Net price: $17,832
- SAT range: 1340-1520
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $63,400
- Overall rank: #25
- Location: Notre Dame, Indiana
- Acceptance rate: 19%
- Net price: $29,981
- SAT range: 1400-1550
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $78,400
- Overall rank: #19
- Location: Chicago, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 7%
- Net price: $36,584
- SAT range: 1500-1570
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $68,100
- Overall rank: #16
- Location: Saint Louis, Missouri
- Acceptance rate: 16%
- Net price: $27,233
- SAT range: 1480-1560
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $70,100
- Overall rank: #15
- Location: Evanston, Illinois
- Acceptance rate: 9%
- Net price: $28,344
- SAT range: 1430-1550
- Median earnings six years after graduation: $69,000
- Overall rank: #14
"
You may also like: The Best (and Worst) States for Community College in 2026