Canva
1 / 17#17. Elkhart County
- Average price difference: 0.21% below list
-- Median list price: $244,000
-- Median sale price: $229,950
- Total homes sold: 172
-- Share that sold above list: 29.1%
Counties with the most homes selling under list price in Indiana
It's a tough time to be in the market for a new house. But as peak homebuying season begins, homebuyers are starting to have at least some negotiating power—especially in markets that recorded large price growth over the last few years.
The average 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage rose above 7% at the start of November 2022, the highest level in more than a decade, as the Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rates to combat inflation. Today, rates remain at historic highs; even half of a percentage point change can significantly affect the monthly payments required for a mortgage.
Since mortgage rates were under 4% for the better part of the past decade, many homebuyers locked in far more affordable rates than what's available in today's environment. And sellers aren't exactly coming down on price: Nationally, home prices are still increasing—just more slowly than they did during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Nationally, the median home sale price in March was $420,321, 4.8% higher than the year before. In Indiana, the median sale price was $248,900, while the average price difference was 1.90% below asking.
Stacker compiled a list of counties in Indiana where homes typically sell below list price using data from Redfin.
You may also like: How gas prices have changed in Indiana in the last week
Canva
2 / 17#16. Tippecanoe County
- Average price difference: 0.75% below list
-- Median list price: $299,900
-- Median sale price: $285,000
- Total homes sold: 145
-- Share that sold above list: 32.4%
Canva
3 / 17#15. Howard County
- Average price difference: 0.83% below list
-- Median list price: $176,950
-- Median sale price: $167,450
- Total homes sold: 102
-- Share that sold above list: 28.4%
Canva
4 / 17#14. Allen County
- Average price difference: 0.94% below list
-- Median list price: $249,999
-- Median sale price: $247,500
- Total homes sold: 393
-- Share that sold above list: 27.0%
Canva
5 / 17#13. Hamilton County
- Average price difference: 0.97% below list
-- Median list price: $441,585
-- Median sale price: $405,000
- Total homes sold: 467
-- Share that sold above list: 22.7%
You may also like: Highest-earning counties in Indiana
Canva
6 / 17#12. Clark County
- Average price difference: 0.98% below list
-- Median list price: $263,500
-- Median sale price: $241,745
- Total homes sold: 156
-- Share that sold above list: 26.3%
Canva
7 / 17#11. Boone County
- Average price difference: 1.36% below list
-- Median list price: $384,447
-- Median sale price: $344,997
- Total homes sold: 114
-- Share that sold above list: 11.4%
Roberto Galan // Shutterstock
8 / 17#10. Hendricks County
- Average price difference: 1.38% below list
-- Median list price: $353,000
-- Median sale price: $335,000
- Total homes sold: 223
-- Share that sold above list: 17.9%
Canva
9 / 17#9. Porter County
- Average price difference: 1.41% below list
-- Median list price: $359,900
-- Median sale price: $293,000
- Total homes sold: 134
-- Share that sold above list: 22.4%
Canva
10 / 17#8. Monroe County
- Average price difference: 1.75% below list
-- Median list price: $360,000
-- Median sale price: $320,000
- Total homes sold: 116
-- Share that sold above list: 20.7%
You may also like: Highest-rated Class of 2026 football recruits from Indiana
Roberto Galan // Shutterstock
11 / 17#7. Johnson County
- Average price difference: 1.76% below list
-- Median list price: $340,000
-- Median sale price: $320,000
- Total homes sold: 173
-- Share that sold above list: 15.6%
Sean Pavone // Shutterstock
12 / 17#6. Marion County
- Average price difference: 1.78% below list
-- Median list price: $264,900
-- Median sale price: $240,000
- Total homes sold: 1,126
-- Share that sold above list: 23.2%
Canva
13 / 17#5. Lake County
- Average price difference: 2.34% below list
-- Median list price: $267,000
-- Median sale price: $254,000
- Total homes sold: 502
-- Share that sold above list: 16.9%
Canva
14 / 17#4. Vanderburgh County
- Average price difference: 2.42% below list
-- Median list price: $182,950
-- Median sale price: $185,375
- Total homes sold: 197
-- Share that sold above list: 23.9%
Canva
15 / 17#3. St. Joseph County
- Average price difference: 2.51% below list
-- Median list price: $199,450
-- Median sale price: $177,750
- Total homes sold: 272
-- Share that sold above list: 24.3%
You may also like: Highest-rated Class of 2027 football recruits from Indiana
Roberto Galan // Shutterstock
16 / 17#2. Delaware County
- Average price difference: 3.53% below list
-- Median list price: $144,000
-- Median sale price: $163,750
- Total homes sold: 104
-- Share that sold above list: 22.1%
Canva
17 / 17#1. Madison County
- Average price difference: 3.53% below list
-- Median list price: $189,950
-- Median sale price: $200,000
- Total homes sold: 153
-- Share that sold above list: 20.3%
This story features data reporting and writing by Elena Cox and is part of a series utilizing data automation across 28 states.
