The most expensive neighborhoods in Michigan City
The most expensive neighborhoods in Michigan City
Homebuyers and sellers are navigating a slow and expensive housing market, with rising prices and stagnant demand keeping many on the sidelines. This comes amid rising economic uncertainty and growing wealth concentration. But luxury homes—multimillion-dollar estates, sleek penthouses, and one-of-a-kind custom builds—are still selling, even as most buyers pull back.
Most people can't afford high-end homes, although they're still fun to dream about. So, to highlight where luxury real estate is commanding the highest prices, Redfin analyzed the most expensive neighborhoods in the Michigan City metro area—and showcased a few of the area's standout listings (when possible).
Note: Redfin's analysis focused on metro areas, meaning some neighborhoods fell within smaller nearby cities. Listings and data were gathered on October 15, 2025.
#1. Midtown (Michigan City, IN)
Median sale price: $177,500 | Median days on market: 39 days1401 Buffalo St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $179,900
- Beds: 2 | Baths: 1.75 | Square feet: 696
- See 1401 Buffalo St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
222 May Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $189,900
- Beds: 2 | Baths: 1 | Square feet: 1,138
- See 222 May Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
515 Dupage St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $199,000
- Beds: 2 | Baths: 1.75 | Square feet: 2,108
- See 515 Dupage St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
517 E Barker Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $295,000
- Beds: not available | Baths: not available | Square feet: not available
- See 517 E Barker Ave, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
#2. Eastport (Michigan City, IN)
Median sale price: $155,000 | Median days on market: 48 days403 Cloud St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $189,000
- Beds: 4 | Baths: 1.5 | Square feet: 1,683
- See 403 Cloud St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
509 Fir St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $212,000
- Beds: 4 | Baths: 1.75 | Square feet: 2,391
- See 509 Fir St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
523 Grace St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $189,000
- Beds: 3 | Baths: 1 | Square feet: 1,392
- See 523 Grace St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
534 Holliday St, Michigan City, IN 46360
- List price: $179,900
- Beds: 3 | Baths: 2 | Square feet: 1,808
- See 534 Holliday St, Michigan City, IN 46360 on Redfin.com
