Do you have to pay employees extra for Thanksgiving?

A businesswoman smiling and writing in a notebook behind a bakery counter surrounded by shelves of bread and pastries. — Alfonso Soler // Shutterstock
A businesswoman smiling and writing in a notebook behind a bakery counter surrounded by shelves of bread and pastries. — Alfonso Soler // Shutterstock

Under federal law, you’re typically not required to pay employees extra for holidays. However, your business’s policies and your state’s rules can change this. The U.S. Department of Labor says the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) doesn't require payment for time not worked, such as holidays, and treats those benefits as a matter of agreement between you and your employees.

Since the FLSA doesn’t have a strict law in place for pay, it falls on your documentation to be the guide. As Rocket Lawyer examines here, what you've promised in your handbook, offer letters, or past practice often matters most, with state and local laws also adding requirements.

What is the legal requirement for holiday pay?

The FLSA asks for very little regarding holiday pay. Again, they don’t require payment for time not worked, but you are free to offer it. The one rule they still have in place is overtime. Nonexempt employees earn time and a half for any hour over the 40-hour workweek, and any holiday hours worked will count toward that week's 40 hours.

Your own employee handbook may have more rules in place. If your handbook, an offer letter, an employment agreement, a union contract, or any other business document promises holiday pay, you must plan to honor it. The same rule applies to a holiday premium you’ve paid every year, since employees may reasonably expect it again. Some states and cities have their own rules surrounding these situations. For example, Rhode Island generally has premium pay rules for retail employees who work certain holidays. Be sure to check each place you have staff, as remote workers are entitled to the laws of the state they are based in.

What if you close during the holiday?

Closing for Thanksgiving or even the day after can affect hourly and salaried employees.

Hourly (nonexempt) employees. Federal law doesn't require you to pay them for a day they don't work. If you do pay them for the day off, those paid hours don't count toward the 40-hour overtime threshold, because they weren't actually worked.

Salaried (exempt) employees. The rules are stricter here. DOL Fact Sheet #17G explains that if you take deductions from an employee's predetermined salary because of the business's operating needs, that employee isn't paid on a "salary basis." In general, an exempt employee who works any part of the week must get their full salary. Improper deductions can put the exemption at risk. You can usually ask exempt employees to use paid time off for the day you're closed, as long as their paycheck stays the same. If they don't have enough PTO left, you still owe their full salary for that week.

No matter your holiday pay policy, be sure to apply this policy in the same way to everyone in the same situation. Be sure to write down all qualifications for your policy, and how much pay eligible employees will receive (if any).

Questions to ask before Thanksgiving

  • What does my current documentation say about holiday pay? Is there an expectation based on past years?
  • How would closing for the holidays affect my employees' pay, and am I sure I'm not cutting pay for exempt employees?
  • If someone works Thanksgiving, will they go over 40 hours that week? Are their hours tracked correctly?
  • Does my policy spell out who qualifies for holiday pay? Am I following it the same way for everyone?

What to do next

  1. Review your paperwork. Check your handbook, offer letters, and any agreements for holiday pay language.
  2. Check your state and local rules. Look at every place you have employees, including remote workers in other states.
  3. Write a short holiday pay policy. Cover which holidays, who qualifies, and what rate applies.
  4. Tell your team early. Share holiday hours and pay details ahead of time, and talk to an attorney if you're unsure about exempt employees or state rules.

Thanksgiving is Thursday, Nov. 26, so there's still time to check what you've promised and tell your team how holiday pay will work.

This story was produced by Rocket Lawyer and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.