How to turn holiday shoppers into reviewers

A person holding a smartphone and a coffee cup alongside overlaid five-star ratings and review bubbles. — New Africa // Shutterstock
A person holding a smartphone and a coffee cup alongside overlaid five-star ratings and review bubbles. — New Africa // Shutterstock

You’ve worked hard to build your business and grow your brand’s online reputation. The reviews customers leave along the way can have a significant impact on how others perceive your business, shaping first impressions and influencing purchasing decisions. According to BrightLocal's 2026 consumer review survey, the vast majority (85%) of consumers are more likely to use a business after reading positive reviews, and an overwhelming majority (93%) have made a purchase after reading them. Reviews can also directly influence sales. Northwestern’s Spiegel Research Center found that displaying reviews raised conversion rates (the percentage of visitors who make a purchase) by up to 190% for lower-priced products and up to 380% for higher-priced ones.

As many business owners and marketers have experienced, getting those reviews is more difficult than it sounds. Businesses need a reliable way to ask customers for reviews, and often only a fraction will respond. It’s also important to make sure your reviews are visible on sites potential customers will see, whether it’s your own website or third-party review sites that appear in Google results and AI-powered searches.

Customers expect a steady flow of reviews, too. The same BrightLocal survey found that nearly three-quarters (74%) of consumers only consider reviews from the past three months, and nearly half (47%) won’t use a business with fewer than 20 reviews.

The holiday season is the best time of year to address this challenge. Shoppers are expected to spend a record $275.1 billion online between Nov. 1 and Dec. 31, according to Adobe’s 2026 holiday forecast, with nearly $48 billion of that spending during Cyber Week alone. More orders mean more customers to ask for a review in a short window of time. Setting up a simple review strategy now can help you benefit from this spending surge and develop a system that keeps working long after the rush. Here, SmartCustomer presents three fundamental steps to implement an effective strategy. 

1. Choose a review management solution

Start by deciding how you’ll collect and manage reviews. Most businesses choose from three options.

Manage reviews in-house. Ask customers directly through follow-up emails or texts. Some businesses build their own automated workflows. This option is cost-efficient; however, it takes ongoing effort and is hard to scale.

Use a review tool. These tools typically collect reviews for your own website so you can use them as marketing assets, but they don’t publish reviews on a public review site.

Use a review platform. Platforms typically include more robust collection tools, plus a public reviews site, and sometimes, the ability to publish your reviews on other sites customers rely on.

Buying a review solution can be more cost-effective and less labor-intensive than building one. Review platforms are advanced, and there are options for nearly every budget, so buying saves time and resources compared to a custom build. 

The easiest place to start is a free review management tool or platform. How to choose a vendor depends on your priority—if it’s solely to publish reviews on your site, opt for a quick and easy integration to your website builder. If your goal is to eventually manage your online reputation with both brand and product reviews, pick a solution that has the ability to get your reviews in front of customers wherever they search, not just on one site. Sending reviews to other sites is usually a paid upgrade. But even if you aren’t ready to pay for that option yet, starting on a platform that offers it means you won't have to switch tools as your business grows. Some platforms also run seasonal promotions built for the holiday rush. 

2. Set up automated review collection

Automation is the most reliable way to keep up with holiday order volume. The simplest automated option most review solutions offer is a dedicated email address you BCC on every order confirmation. The system registers each order and sends that customer a review request based on your selected schedule and method, such as emails, texts, QR codes, website prompts, or in-app notifications. A strong review solution offers multiple ways to collect reviews and integrates with your website and marketing tools to make the process seamless.

If you’re not ready to automate the process, many review platforms let you upload your customer list using a CSV file, making it easy to get started. You can upload your holiday orders in one batch once the rush slows down. Follow the guidelines set by review platforms and the FTC. That means sending requests to every customer, not only the ones you expect to be happy. Asking only satisfied customers, a practice known as review gating, directly violates those guidelines. 

3. Publish and monitor your reviews

Reviews need to be presented to your customers when they’re deciding whether to buy. If you’re managing reviews in-house, use your website builder to embed them on your site. Review tools and platforms offer widgets that display reviews on your site with little setup, and most let you customize how they look.

If your solution can send reviews to other sites, choose the ones that your customers care about, are trusted in your industry, show up in Google, and get cited in AI search results. AI is quickly becoming more influential. More than three-quarters of consumers (76%) used AI to help with shopping in the past year, according to SmartCustomer’s 2026 AI Shopping Survey. Adobe also expects traffic from AI tools to U.S. retail sites to more than double (up 130%) this holiday season.

Once reviews start coming in, check them regularly through the rush and respond, particularly to negative ones. A thoughtful reply shows future customers (and AI models) how you handle problems. 

Turn holiday reviews into year-round momentum

The holiday rush brings more opportunities than any other time of year to turn customers into reviewers, which means more reviews and a faster path to fresh feedback and a representative rating. The system you set up now can continue to pay off even after the season ends. Because most customers only trust reviews from the last few months, a steady stream of new ones keeps your reputation current and lets you focus on running your business.

This story was produced by SmartCustomer and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.