Best seasons in Indianapolis Colts history

With over a century of history that dates back to 1920, the NFL has plenty of memorable seasons.

In the 2016 season, for instance, Tom Brady was suspended his first four games before he orchestrated a miraculous 28-3 comeback to cap the year in the Super Bowl. Then there's the 1985 Chicago Bears and their Super Bowl Shuffle. The 2004 season saw a trio of astounding feats, with Peyton Manning breaking Dan Marino's long-standing passing touchdown record, a rookie quarterback leading Pittsburgh to a 15-1 record, and Philadelphia's Terrell Owens lighting up the league at wide receiver before a broken leg ended his regular season. The strike seasons of 1982 and 1987 were memorable in their own, unique ways, too. And who could forget the 1972 Miami Dolphins, the only team to win a Super Bowl with a perfect record.

It's hard to single out the best NFL season—and harder still to try and qualify or quantify what "best" really is.

But what about the best seasons of a single team? Can we determine the best seasons in a team's history?

To a degree, that's quantifiable, and where this list comes in. Stacker compiled the top 10 best seasons in Indianapolis Colts history using Pro-Football-Reference.com data that goes back to the first NFL season in 1920. Seasons were ranked based on how far the team progressed in the playoffs in a particular year. Any ties were broken first by each season's regular season record, then by net points per game. Supplemental data points include the team's head coach and, for years after 1931, top passers, rushers, and receivers of specific seasons.

Read on through to find out which seasons count as the Indianapolis Colts' best. Of course, there's wiggle room to define what makes a season one of the "best"—take a peek below to see if you agree with how the rankings played out.

#10. 2014
- Regular season record: 11-5
- Playoffs: Lost in conference championship
- Points per game: 28.6
- Opponent points per game: 23.1
- Net points per game: 5.6
- Head coach: Chuck Pagano
- Top passer: Andrew Luck
- Top rusher: Trent Richardson
- Top receiver: T.Y. Hilton

#9. 1971 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 10-4
- Playoffs: Lost in conference championship
- Points per game: 22.4
- Opponent points per game: 10.0
- Net points per game: 12.4
- Head coach: Don McCafferty
- Top passer: Earl Morrall
- Top rusher: Norm Bulaich
- Top receiver: Eddie Hinton

#8. 2003
- Regular season record: 12-4
- Playoffs: Lost in conference championship
- Points per game: 27.9
- Opponent points per game: 21.0
- Net points per game: 6.9
- Head coach: Tony Dungy
- Top passer: Peyton Manning
- Top rusher: Edgerrin James
- Top receiver: Marvin Harrison

#7. 1964 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 12-2
- Playoffs: Lost in NFL championship
- Points per game: 30.6
- Opponent points per game: 16.1
- Net points per game: 14.5
- Head coach: Don Shula
- Top passer: Johnny Unitas
- Top rusher: Lenny Moore
- Top receiver: Jimmy Orr

#6. 2009
- Regular season record: 14-2
- Playoffs: Lost in Super Bowl
- Points per game: 26.0
- Opponent points per game: 19.2
- Net points per game: 6.8
- Head coach: Jim Caldwell
- Top passer: Peyton Manning
- Top rusher: Joseph Addai
- Top receiver: Reggie Wayne

#5. 1968 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 13-1
- Playoffs: Lost in Super Bowl
- Points per game: 28.7
- Opponent points per game: 10.3
- Net points per game: 18.4
- Head coach: Don Shula
- Top passer: Earl Morrall
- Top rusher: Tom Matte
- Top receiver: Jimmy Orr

#4. 2006
- Regular season record: 12-4
- Playoffs: Won Super Bowl
- Points per game: 26.7
- Opponent points per game: 22.5
- Net points per game: 4.2
- Head coach: Tony Dungy
- Top passer: Peyton Manning
- Top rusher: Joseph Addai
- Top receiver: Marvin Harrison

#3. 1959 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 9-3
- Playoffs: Won NFL championship
- Points per game: 31.2
- Opponent points per game: 20.9
- Net points per game: 10.3
- Head coach: Weeb Ewbank
- Top passer: Johnny Unitas
- Top rusher: Alan Ameche
- Top receiver: Raymond Berry

#2. 1958 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 9-3
- Playoffs: Won NFL championship
- Points per game: 31.8
- Opponent points per game: 16.9
- Net points per game: 14.8
- Head coach: Weeb Ewbank
- Top passer: Johnny Unitas
- Top rusher: Alan Ameche
- Top receiver: Lenny Moore

#1. 1970 (as the Baltimore Colts)
- Regular season record: 11-2-1
- Playoffs: Won Super Bowl
- Points per game: 22.9
- Opponent points per game: 16.7
- Net points per game: 6.2
- Head coach: Don McCafferty
- Top passer: Johnny Unitas
- Top rusher: Norm Bulaich
- Top receiver: Roy Jefferson