Counties with the most super commuters in New York

Written by:
August 19, 2022
Sundry Photography // Shutterstock

Counties with the most super commuters in New York

There are more than 283 million vehicles on the road in the United States, and many of those cars, trucks, vans, and motorcycles are used to ferry people to and from their homes and jobs during their daily commutes. A small but growing number of people are walking and biking to work, particularly in compact college towns. Many more take public transportation, especially in major cities like New York, Chicago, San Francisco, Washington D.C., Boston, and Seattle—but nationwide, public transit accounts for only about 5% of daily commutes.

The overwhelming majority of people still drive to and from work every day, and the vast majority of those car commuters drive alone—fewer than 10% of Americans carpool. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the average one-way commute in the United States has grown to a record 26.9 minutes. That's just shy of an hour a day that average Americans squander behind the wheel, not at home with their families, and instead, burning gas and putting miles on their cars.

For some Americans, however, the commute to work is far from average. A phenomenon known as super commuting has emerged and grown in recent years. Super commuters spend 90 minutes or more—each way—chasing their paychecks every day. The biggest percentage of super commuters work in the extraction industry, with workers pursuing lucrative jobs in remote mines, oil fields, and other energy operations. Many more, however, have been priced out of expensive housing in urban metro areas where high-paying jobs are located, far away from their less-expensive county of residence.

Stacker compiled a list of counties with the most super commuters in New York using data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Counties are ranked by the highest percent of workers with a commute over 90 minutes, based on 2020 5-year estimates. Keep reading to see where in your state people are spending the most time going to and from work every day.

#50. Onondaga County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.3%
--- 60+ minute commute: 3.2%
- Average commute time: 20 minutes
--- 13.5 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 9.0%
- Worked outside county of residence: 6.5%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.8%), carpooled (8.1%), walked to work (3.6%), public transportation (2.6%), worked from home (6.4%)

#49. Montgomery County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.3%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.1%
- Average commute time: 24.5 minutes
--- 9.0 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 19.0%
- Worked outside county of residence: 44.1%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (78.8%), carpooled (8.1%), walked to work (3.7%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (5.5%)

#48. Seneca County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.3%
- Average commute time: 21.7 minutes
--- 11.8 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 40.4%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (78.8%), carpooled (9.8%), walked to work (2.8%), public transportation (0.6%), worked from home (5.2%)

#47. Cortland County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.0%
- Average commute time: 21.3 minutes
--- 12.2 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 29.1%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (76.6%), carpooled (11.0%), walked to work (5.0%), public transportation (0.9%), worked from home (5.1%)

#46. Oneida County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.4%
- Average commute time: 19.9 minutes
--- 13.6 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 12.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (80.1%), carpooled (8.6%), walked to work (3.5%), public transportation (1.2%), worked from home (5.8%)

#45. Jefferson County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 3.0%
- Average commute time: 18.8 minutes
--- 14.7 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 20.2%
- Worked outside county of residence: 5.1%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.7%), carpooled (8.3%), walked to work (5.2%), public transportation (0.6%), worked from home (6.3%)

#44. Franklin County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 6.5%
- Average commute time: 20.1 minutes
--- 13.4 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.3%
- Worked outside county of residence: 18.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.8%), carpooled (9.6%), walked to work (3.3%), public transportation (1.0%), worked from home (6.8%)

#43. Livingston County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 6.4%
- Average commute time: 25.1 minutes
--- 8.4 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 44.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (79.9%), carpooled (7.7%), walked to work (5.8%), public transportation (0.6%), worked from home (4.9%)

#42. Madison County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.5%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.5%
- Average commute time: 24 minutes
--- 9.5 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 50.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (79.7%), carpooled (7.9%), walked to work (4.9%), public transportation (0.4%), worked from home (6.1%)

#41. Wyoming County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 9.3%
- Average commute time: 25.7 minutes
--- 7.8 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 13.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 45.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (82.1%), carpooled (6.0%), walked to work (6.4%), public transportation (0.5%), worked from home (4.3%)

#40. Saratoga County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.9%
- Average commute time: 25.3 minutes
--- 8.2 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 9.9%
- Worked outside county of residence: 40.0%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (81.7%), carpooled (6.8%), walked to work (1.8%), public transportation (0.8%), worked from home (8.5%)

#39. Tioga County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.3%
- Average commute time: 23.8 minutes
--- 9.7 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.2%
- Worked outside county of residence: 47.4%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (83.0%), carpooled (8.4%), walked to work (2.2%), public transportation (0.4%), worked from home (4.5%)

#38. Fulton County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 9.7%
- Average commute time: 24.5 minutes
--- 9.0 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 18.2%
- Worked outside county of residence: 41.9%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (82.3%), carpooled (9.3%), walked to work (2.4%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (3.4%)

#37. Broome County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.1%
- Average commute time: 19.2 minutes
--- 14.3 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 9.9%
- Worked outside county of residence: 8.9%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (79.0%), carpooled (8.7%), walked to work (3.7%), public transportation (3.1%), worked from home (4.5%)

#36. Orleans County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.0%
- Average commute time: 25.6 minutes
--- 7.9 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 21.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 45.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.8%), carpooled (11.5%), walked to work (4.1%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (4.3%)

#35. Steuben County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.8%
--- 60+ minute commute: 6.6%
- Average commute time: 22 minutes
--- 11.5 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.1%
- Worked outside county of residence: 21.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (78.9%), carpooled (9.9%), walked to work (3.6%), public transportation (0.5%), worked from home (5.6%)

#34. Cayuga County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.8%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.5%
- Average commute time: 23.3 minutes
--- 10.2 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 38.0%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (83.3%), carpooled (6.1%), walked to work (3.9%), public transportation (0.7%), worked from home (4.3%)

#33. St. Lawrence County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 1.9%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.0%
- Average commute time: 20.9 minutes
--- 12.6 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 10.6%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (76.6%), carpooled (10.1%), walked to work (5.9%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (5.7%)

#32. Warren County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.1%
- Average commute time: 22.4 minutes
--- 11.1 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.0%
- Worked outside county of residence: 30.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (82.2%), carpooled (7.4%), walked to work (3.0%), public transportation (0.8%), worked from home (5.0%)

#31. Cattaraugus County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.6%
- Average commute time: 22.1 minutes
--- 11.4 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.3%
- Worked outside county of residence: 26.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (80.6%), carpooled (8.0%), walked to work (4.8%), public transportation (0.5%), worked from home (4.8%)

#30. Rensselaer County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.1%
- Average commute time: 24.3 minutes
--- 9.2 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 52.3%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (79.2%), carpooled (7.5%), walked to work (3.1%), public transportation (2.9%), worked from home (6.0%)

#29. Chemung County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 4.3%
- Average commute time: 19.5 minutes
--- 14.0 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 11.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 18.9%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (81.8%), carpooled (8.5%), walked to work (3.2%), public transportation (1.4%), worked from home (3.6%)

#28. Washington County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.7%
- Average commute time: 26.3 minutes
--- 7.2 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 17.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 47.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (82.5%), carpooled (8.1%), walked to work (3.1%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (4.7%)

#27. Oswego County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.4%
- Average commute time: 24.8 minutes
--- 8.7 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 17.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 39.3%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (81.4%), carpooled (7.7%), walked to work (3.5%), public transportation (0.8%), worked from home (4.5%)

#26. Chenango County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 7.9%
- Average commute time: 24.4 minutes
--- 9.1 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 18.9%
- Worked outside county of residence: 32.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (80.0%), carpooled (9.8%), walked to work (4.4%), public transportation (0.1%), worked from home (4.6%)

#25. Herkimer County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.6%
- Average commute time: 23.6 minutes
--- 9.9 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 16.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 45.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (80.6%), carpooled (7.9%), walked to work (4.5%), public transportation (0.6%), worked from home (5.5%)

#24. Otsego County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 6.5%
- Average commute time: 23 minutes
--- 10.5 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.1%
- Worked outside county of residence: 21.0%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (76.3%), carpooled (8.4%), walked to work (7.2%), public transportation (1.6%), worked from home (5.3%)

#23. Allegany County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 6.7%
- Average commute time: 22.2 minutes
--- 11.3 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 28.1%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (75.7%), carpooled (7.5%), walked to work (10.3%), public transportation (0.3%), worked from home (4.7%)

#22. Hamilton County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 12.1%
- Average commute time: 23.5 minutes
--- 10.0 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.3%
- Worked outside county of residence: 29.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.8%), carpooled (2.5%), walked to work (8.7%), public transportation (0.6%), worked from home (9.3%)

#21. Schuyler County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 5.4%
- Average commute time: 27.9 minutes
--- 5.6 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.2%
- Worked outside county of residence: 54.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.1%), carpooled (13.1%), walked to work (2.8%), public transportation (0.2%), worked from home (6.0%)

#20. Manhattan

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 2.8%
--- 60+ minute commute: 10.9%
- Average commute time: 32.1 minutes
--- 1.4 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 3.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 10.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (5.8%), carpooled (1.9%), walked to work (19.7%), public transportation (54.9%), worked from home (12.0%)

#19. Columbia County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 3.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 8.2%
- Average commute time: 25.8 minutes
--- 7.7 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.8%
- Worked outside county of residence: 31.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (74.7%), carpooled (6.9%), walked to work (3.8%), public transportation (2.7%), worked from home (9.4%)

#18. Schoharie County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 3.1%
--- 60+ minute commute: 14.9%
- Average commute time: 30.7 minutes
--- 2.8 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 20.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 43.0%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.7%), carpooled (9.8%), walked to work (4.7%), public transportation (0.7%), worked from home (6.4%)

#17. Greene County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 3.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 8.6%
- Average commute time: 28.7 minutes
--- 4.8 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.8%
- Worked outside county of residence: 41.5%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (78.7%), carpooled (8.1%), walked to work (2.7%), public transportation (1.3%), worked from home (7.2%)

#16. Essex County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 3.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 8.8%
- Average commute time: 23.6 minutes
--- 9.9 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 13.9%
- Worked outside county of residence: 21.6%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (76.6%), carpooled (9.9%), walked to work (3.3%), public transportation (0.4%), worked from home (8.1%)

#15. Lewis County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 3.7%
--- 60+ minute commute: 8.9%
- Average commute time: 24.4 minutes
--- 9.1 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 21.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 35.0%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (77.7%), carpooled (11.0%), walked to work (4.8%), public transportation (0.7%), worked from home (5.0%)

#14. Delaware County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 4.8%
--- 60+ minute commute: 8.7%
- Average commute time: 26.1 minutes
--- 7.4 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 16.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 25.6%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (75.1%), carpooled (7.7%), walked to work (6.4%), public transportation (1.3%), worked from home (7.3%)

#13. Ulster County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 5.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 10.5%
- Average commute time: 28.4 minutes
--- 5.1 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 31.3%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (75.2%), carpooled (7.7%), walked to work (3.3%), public transportation (2.4%), worked from home (9.6%)

#12. Rockland County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 6.8%
--- 60+ minute commute: 17.2%
- Average commute time: 31.6 minutes
--- 1.9 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 8.2%
- Worked outside county of residence: 27.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (70.5%), carpooled (9.1%), walked to work (3.5%), public transportation (7.8%), worked from home (7.0%)

#11. Westchester County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 7.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 22.0%
- Average commute time: 35.3 minutes
--- 1.8 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 7.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 31.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (55.6%), carpooled (7.8%), walked to work (4.3%), public transportation (21.8%), worked from home (8.9%)

#10. Staten Island

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 7.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 28.4%
- Average commute time: 43 minutes
--- 9.5 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 7.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 46.8%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (18.3%), carpooled (4.1%), walked to work (8.6%), public transportation (57.8%), worked from home (7.9%)

#9. Sullivan County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 7.3%
--- 60+ minute commute: 12.8%
- Average commute time: 29.7 minutes
--- 3.8 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 14.3%
- Worked outside county of residence: 30.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (81.3%), carpooled (6.3%), walked to work (2.2%), public transportation (2.0%), worked from home (6.5%)

#8. Suffolk County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 7.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 15.4%
- Average commute time: 32.4 minutes
--- 1.1 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 11.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 22.7%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (78.1%), carpooled (7.7%), walked to work (1.2%), public transportation (6.0%), worked from home (5.5%)

#7. Dutchess County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 7.6%
--- 60+ minute commute: 16.7%
- Average commute time: 32.8 minutes
--- 0.7 minutes shorter than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.1%
- Worked outside county of residence: 31.4%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (75.3%), carpooled (7.1%), walked to work (3.4%), public transportation (4.8%), worked from home (7.9%)

#6. Nassau County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 8.0%
--- 60+ minute commute: 23.8%
- Average commute time: 36.6 minutes
--- 3.1 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 9.9%
- Worked outside county of residence: 41.1%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (66.4%), carpooled (7.2%), walked to work (2.2%), public transportation (16.0%), worked from home (7.1%)

#5. Putnam County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 9.2%
--- 60+ minute commute: 23.3%
- Average commute time: 40 minutes
--- 6.5 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.7%
- Worked outside county of residence: 59.6%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (74.7%), carpooled (8.0%), walked to work (1.2%), public transportation (7.8%), worked from home (7.6%)

#4. Queens

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 9.3%
--- 60+ minute commute: 31.2%
- Average commute time: 44.2 minutes
--- 10.7 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 10.4%
- Worked outside county of residence: 53.2%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (32.5%), carpooled (6.3%), walked to work (5.8%), public transportation (48.2%), worked from home (5.4%)

#3. Orange County

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 9.5%
--- 60+ minute commute: 20.3%
- Average commute time: 34.4 minutes
--- 0.9 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 15.5%
- Worked outside county of residence: 26.6%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (73.8%), carpooled (8.9%), walked to work (3.6%), public transportation (5.1%), worked from home (6.7%)

#2. Bronx

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 9.9%
--- 60+ minute commute: 35.5%
- Average commute time: 45.3 minutes
--- 11.8 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 13.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 53.4%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (24.2%), carpooled (4.4%), walked to work (7.3%), public transportation (57.4%), worked from home (4.4%)

#1. Brooklyn

- Workers with 90+ minute commute: 14.4%
--- 60+ minute commute: 35.3%
- Average commute time: 44.6 minutes
--- 11.1 minutes longer than state average
- Left for work from 12 a.m. to 6 a.m.: 12.6%
- Worked outside county of residence: 42.3%
- Means of transportation: drove alone (55.8%), carpooled (7.8%), walked to work (2.8%), public transportation (28.0%), worked from home (4.4%)

Trending Now