Cities with the fastest 'time-to-crime' rates for firearms
Cities with the fastest 'time-to-crime' rates for firearms
The average time between the purchase of a gun and its recovery from a crime scene has gotten shorter in recent years, 2023 data from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives shows.
This span of time, known as "time-to-crime," is used to gauge levels of criminal intent in the purchase of firearms, as well as to deduce where hubs of gun trafficking are. A shorter time-to-crime indicates that weapons were likely purchased with criminal intent and might be objects of firearms trafficking.
The ATF traces firearms in order to aid law enforcement in generating suspect leads when guns are used in crimes, as well as to ascertain how and where guns are moved. To do this, members of law enforcement must voluntarily submit trace requests to the ATF, which can evaluate a gun's place of manufacture and where it was first purchased.
Because not all recovered crime guns are reported to the ATF, with some police departments reporting more consistently than others, the accuracy of time-to-crime rates by city or region can be questionable. In Chicago, for instance, the number of gun traces leads other major cities by a significant amount.
Even with inconsistencies in reporting, gun tracing has revealed that some parts of the U.S. serve as hubs for firearms trafficking. Known as the "iron pipeline," gun traffickers notoriously take advantage of lax gun laws in some states in the Southern and Midwestern U.S., bringing them to states with stricter gun laws, particularly in the Northeast and on the West Coast. As a result, just 10 states—including Indiana, Georgia, Texas, and Virginia—are the source of large quantities of guns recovered at crime scenes in New York and California.
In 2020, there was a significant increase in recovered guns with short time-to-crime rates, with numbers nearly doubling from the previous year. This spike came as homicide rates and gun sales in the U.S. also saw dramatic increases. The full impact of the role of soaring gun sales and shorter time-to-crime rates on higher murder rates in 2020 is not yet known. Due to inconsistent gun tracing practices from police departments across the country, an incomplete picture of the true scope of short time-to-crime rates remains.
Stacker compiled gun crime data from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives on 40 cities across the U.S. and ranked them by five-year median time-to-crime rates. Ties were broken by the percentage of guns used in crimes successfully linked to the known purchaser. Analyzed crime guns were recovered and traced between 2017 and 2021 for 40 cities in the U.S. ranging in size—mega, large, medium, and small.
#40. New York City
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 6.3 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 12,910 (67.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 4.5
#39. Baltimore
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 5.3 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 8,057 (60.4% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 44.9
#38. San Jose, California
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 4.6 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 1,536 (67.1% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 4.5
#37. San Diego
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 4.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 3,301 (57.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 8.1
#36. Los Angeles
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 4.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 19,649 (63.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 15.7
#35. San Bernardino, California
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 4.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 3,299 (69.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 43.0
#34. Jacksonville, Florida
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 11,735 (86.2% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 29.5
#33. Tampa, Florida
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 8,595 (82.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 53.7
#32. Chattanooga, Tennessee
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3.1 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,434 (76.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 63.9
#31. Wichita, Kansas
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3.1 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 5,534 (81.1% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 34.7
#30. Tulsa, Oklahoma
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3.1 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 6,570 (85.2% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 37.9
#29. Winston-Salem, North Carolina
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 3 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,008 (77.3% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 41.9
#28. New Orleans
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.9 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 7,497 (83.1% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 46.8
#27. Orlando, Florida
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.9 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 9,789 (87.6% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 75.9
#26. Chicago
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.8 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 37,680 (74.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 37.2
#25. Dayton, Ohio
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.8 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,089 (80.2% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 73.4
#24. Cincinnati
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.7 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 8,484 (85.0% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 65.4
#23. Miami
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.5 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 7,133 (81.4% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 38.8
#22. Indianapolis
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.5 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 16,589 (82.0% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 46.4
#21. Charlotte, North Carolina
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.5 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 11,882 (82.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 33.0
#20. Baton Rouge, Louisiana
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.5 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 7,339 (85.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 76.4
#19. Louisville, Kentucky
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 11,785 (76.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 49.1
#18. Las Vegas
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 18,867 (80.7% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 72.6
#17. Columbus, Ohio
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 12,147 (82.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 32.8
#16. Dallas
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 16,722 (84.6% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 30.1
#15. San Antonio
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.4 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 14,868 (85.5% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 23.5
#14. Philadelphia
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.3 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 16,626 (70.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 29.7
#13. Houston
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.3 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 38,839 (84.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 39.8
#12. Cleveland
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 7,851 (81.4% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 51.2
#11. Huntsville, Alabama
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,929 (85.4% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 56.1
#10. Mobile, Alabama
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,757 (87.0% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 58.3
#9. Milwaukee
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 13,072 (88.3% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 50.9
#8. Atlanta
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2.1 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 13,035 (85.0% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 62.4
#7. Shreveport, Louisiana
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 2 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 4,550 (85.7% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 56.5
#6. Memphis, Tennessee
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.9 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 19,369 (78.1% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 77.5
#5. St. Louis
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.9 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 12,289 (83.8% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 97.5
#4. Phoenix
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.8 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 13,294 (84.1% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 19.4
#3. Columbia, South Carolina
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.7 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 5,489 (87.4% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 96.9
#2. Detroit
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.6 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 21,881 (83.9% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 79.9
#1. Richmond, Virginia
- Median time-to-crime from 2017 to 2021: 1.5 years
--- Crime guns traced to known purchaser: 5,764 (81.7% of all crime guns)
--- Average annual traced crime guns per 10k residents: 62.2
