50 Scary-Sugary Candies for this Halloween

Written by:
October 24, 2017
Updated on October 25, 2017
gsk2014 // Shutterstock

50 Scary-Sugary Candies for this Halloween

For many, the scariest thing about Halloween isn't the ghouls or the goblins, but the amount of sugar in your kids' favorite treats. Refined or processed sugar can lead to tooth decay, obesity, and behavioral issues in children, so it is important to take note of how much sugar you and your kids consume this Halloween.

At Stacker, we used the ESHA's Nutritional database of over 70,000 different food items to rank which 50 candies have the greatest sugar content, as represented by grams of sugar over total weight. For candies with the same sugar ratio, we looked to the total grams of sugar and total calories to break the tie. Homemade recipes, private-label candy brands, and smaller regional brands were removed from the list.

We begin with the fiftieth most sugary candy and work our way to number one. After reading our list, you may be tempted to say, "trick, please!" this upcoming Halloween.

#49 Two-Way Tie: Charms Sour Balls

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 6g

Sugar: 4g

Calories: 20

A hard candy classic, each can comes in six flavors and contain 67% sugar.

#49 Two-Way Tie: Charms Squares

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 6g

Sugar: 4g

Calories: 20

Similar to their spherical cousins, Charms Squares are two-thirds sugar and come in packs of ten individually-wrapped candy squares.

#46. Three-Way Tie: Charms Mini Pops

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 10g

Calories: 50

Although these lollipops have “mini” in their title, Charms MiniPops pack a “mega” sugary punch with flavors like Blue Razz, Pink Lemonade, and Bubble Gum.

#46. Three-Way Tie: SweeTarts Mini Chewy

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 10g

Calories: 50

Don’t let their tanginess fool you! SweeTarts Mini Chewys are also part of the two-thirds sugar club.

#46. Three-Way Tie: Original Spree

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 10g

Calories: 50

Our first entrant from The Willy Wonka Candy Company, Original Sprees come in five classic flavors and feature 10g of sugar for every 15g of candy. Original Sprees might look like they could be small pills, but their sugar content is anything but medicinal!

#45. Raisinets

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 45g

Sugar: 30g

Calories: 200

Introduced to America in 1927 by the Blumenthal Brothers Chocolate Company, Raisinets are a classic cinema treat with 67% sugar in every handful.

#44. Brach's Hi-C Orange Slices

ShopWell

Maker: Ferrara Candy

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 45g

Sugar: 30g

Calories: 150

First raisins and now orange slices, will the betrayal ever end? Brach’s Hi-C Orange Slices might help protect you from a cold, but they also check in at 67% sugar.

#43. Three Musketeers

Maker: Mars

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 60g

Sugar: 40g

Calories: 262

Introduced in 1932, this rich chocolate and nougat fusion originally came in packs of three flavors: chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. Whether you like your Three Musketeers traditional or fun-sized, you’ll get a mouthful with two-thirds sugar. 

#42. Trader Joe's All Natural Fruit Jellies

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 67%

Weight: 43g

Sugar: 29g

Calories: 140

If we’ve learned anything from this list, it’s that fruit candies can have their fair share of sugar. Trader Joe’s All Natural Fruit Jellies round out the tier of candies with a sugar ratio of 67%.

#41. Cadbury Milk Chocolate Mini Eggs

Maker: Hershey Company

Sugar Content: 68%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 27g

Calories: 190

For those still holding onto their springtime stockpile, Cadbury Milk Cholocate Mini Eggs come in flavors like white chocolate, dark chocolate, and chocolate crunch creme. With a rich chocolate filling and coated in a speckled candy shell, Cadbury Milk Chocolate Mini Eggs contain 68% sugar.

 

#40. Jolly Rancher Fruit Chews

Maker: Hershey Company

Sugar Content: 68%

Weight: 56g

Sugar: 38g

Calories: 200

Jolly Rancher Fruit Chews are an extravaganza of flavors with 38g sugar for every 50g of candy.

#39. Sunspire Peppermint Pattie

Maker: Hain Celestial Group

Sugar Content: 68%

Weight: 38g

Sugar: 26g

Calories: 170

While they may make your mouth feel fresh, Sunspire Peppermint Patties pack a sugar ratio of 68%.

#38. Giant Chewy Nerds

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 69%

Weight: 51g

Sugar: 35g

Calories: 170

You may think that eating Giant Chewy Nerds is a smart idea, but at 69% sugar, we're not so sure!

#35. Three-Way Tie: Jolly Rancher Lollipops

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 69%

Weight: 16g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 60

Dentists may want to think twice before passing out these lollipops to their patients! With flavors like pink lemonade, cherry, watermelon, and apple, Jolly Rancher Lollipops are 69% sugar.

#35. Three-Way Tie: Charms Lollipops

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 69%

Weight: 16g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 60

The one thing that isn't charming about these lollipops is the high sugar content. These lollipops are 69% sugar!

 

#35. Three-Way Tie: SweeTarts Chewy

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 69%

Weight: 16g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 60

These SweeTarts Chewys are even scarier than their mini SweeTart Chewy counterparts, with 11g of sugar per 16g of Chewy. 

#34. Jellybeans

Maker: Starburst

Sugar Content: 69%

Weight: 42g

Sugar: 29g

Calories: 150

Starburst’s JellyBeans have an incredible amount of sugar for such a small package. For every 42g of Jellybean, you can expect 29g of sugar!

#33. SweeTarts Soft Bites

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 70%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 28g

Calories: 140

SweeTarts Soft Bites are the first candies on our list where the sugar content breaks 70%.

#32. Dark Chocolate Covered Mint Creams

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 70%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 28g

Calories: 170

Dark chocolate and mint make a satisfying combination, but Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Covered Mint Creams have 28g of sugar for every 40g of candy.

#31. Candy-Coated Licorice

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 70%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 28g

Calories: 140

Licorice root may be medicinal, but Candy-Coated Licorice from Trader Joe's still makes our list for top sugary candies.

#30. Dark Chocolate Mints

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 70%

Weight: 57g

Sugar: 40g

Calories: 240

These Dark Chocolate Mints round out the 70% club.

#28. Two- Way Tie: Brach's Candy Corn

Maker: Ferrara Candy

Sugar Content: 72%

Weight: 39g

Sugar: 28g

Calories: 140

This classic Halloween treat is 72% sugar. If you’re looking to give a slight break to your teeth, the Indian Corn version of this candy has a 27g of sugar per 39g of Candy Corn (sugar ratio: 69%).

#28. Two- Way Tie: Gumdrops

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 72%

Weight: 39g

Sugar: 28g

Calories: 140

You may want to skip a trip to the Gumdrop Forest. Gumdrops are 72% sugar!

#27. Charms Junior Blow Pop

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 72%

Weight: 18g

Sugar: 13g

Calories: 70

Charms Junior Blow Pops are 13g of sugar for every 18g lollipop - that is 72% sugar!

#26. Sour Skittles

Maker: Mars

Sugar Content: 73%

Weight: 51g

Sugar: 37g

Calories: 200

Just because these candies bring the sour, doesn't mean that they aren't sweet! Sour Skittles come in at 73% sugar.

#25. Sugar Babies

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 73%

Weight: 41g

Sugar: 30g

Calories: 160

These candies may not be full-grown, but they pack an adult sugar-punch. Sugar Babies are 73% sugar.

#24. Brach's Cinnamon Imperials

Maker: Ferrara Candy

Sugar Content: 73%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 60

 

Brach’s Cinnamon Imperials will conquer your mouth… with sugar. Although these candies are small, they are still 73% sugar.

 

#23. Candied Ginger

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 75%

Weight: 28g

Sugar: 21g

Calories: 100

 

Ginger may have health benefits, but Trader Joe’s Candied Gingers are three-quarters sugar.

#22. Trader Joe's Jellybeans

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 75%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 30g

Calories: 150

 

These tasty Jellybeans are three-quarters sugar! Which flavor will you get?

#21. Hershey's Peppermint Patty

Maker: Hershey's

Sugar Content: 75%

Weight: 100g

Sugar: 75g

Calories: 394

 

You may be dreaming of peppermint patties as the weather gets colder, but practice moderation with these sugary treats!

#20. Skittles (Fun Size)

Maker: Mars

Sugar Content: 76%

Weight: 100g

Sugar: 76g

Calories: 405

 

These Skittles may be fun-sized but for every 100g of candy, they pack 76g of sugar. Wild Berry Skittles may sound healthier for you, but they only have 3 fewer calories and the same amount of sugar.

#19. Dum Dums

Maker: Spangler Candy Company

Sugar Content: 77%

Weight: 13g

Sugar: 10g

Calories: 51

 

After looking at the nutrition facts for Dum Dums, you may start saying “umm umm.” Dum Dums are 77% sugar with 10g of sugar per 13g of weight.

#18. Nerds Rope

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 77%

Weight: 26g

Sugar: 20g

Calories: 90

This skippy candy carries 20g of sugar for every 26g of candy, backing out to 77% sugar.

#17. Spangler Candy Canes, Assorted

Maker: Spangler Candy Company

Sugar Content: 77-80%

Weight: 14g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 40

For those planning on dipping into last year's winter candy stash for this year's Trick-or-Treaters, Spangler Candy Canes enter our list with a range of sugar content. Their Mini Candy Canes have a sugar content of 77%, while their Jumbo Candy Canes cousins reach 80% sugar.

#16. Chewy Spree

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 80%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 12g

Calories: 50

These fun, colorful candies are four-fifths sugar, with 12g of sugar for every 15g of Chewy Spree.

#15. Junior Mints

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 80%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 32g

Calories: 170

While they may be Junior Mints, they carry a senior load of sugar. Junior Mints have 32g of sugar per 40g of candy.

#14. Saf-T-Pops

Maker: Spangler Candy Company

Sugar Content: 82%

Weight: 11g

Sugar: 9g

Calories: 43

While the fully enclosed candy wrapper and looped handle give Saf-T-Pops their name, these candies pack 82% sugar.

#13. Nips

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 86%

Weight: 14g

Sugar: 12g

Calories: 60

These hard caramel candies are silky smooth, but their nutrition facts may make you balk at 86% sugar.

#12. SweeTarts

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 87%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 13g

Calories: 50

 

SweeTarts are tiny, but every bite is 87% sugar.

#10. Two-Way Tie: Bottle Caps

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 87%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 13g

Calories: 60

While Bottle Caps invoke nostalgia with their old-timey look, these candies have an incredible 13g of sugar for every 15g of cap.

#10. Two-Way Tie: Runts

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 87%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 13g

Calories: 60

Runts may be the smallest of the litter, but at 87% sugar content, they are one of the sweetest candies in the pack!

#9. Cry Baby

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 89%

Weight: 5g

Sugar: 4g

Calories: 15

We won’t blame you for weeping after you see the sugar content in these Cry Babies. This treat packs 4g of sugar for every 5g of candy!

#8. Fun Dip

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 92%

Weight: 12g

Sugar: 11g

Calories: 45

With a sugary pouch and famous hard-candy "Lik-a-Stix", it's no surprise that this candy contains 92% sugar.

#7. Candy Blox

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 93%

Weight: 14g

Sugar: 13g

Calories: 50

Candy Blox offer a fun opportunity to play with your food but still make the top ten of our list with 93% sugar.

#6. Circus Peanuts

Maker: Spangler Candy Company

Sugar Content: 93%

Weight: 42g

Sugar: 39g

Calories: 163

 

Harkening back to the days of penny candies and classic candy shoppes, these soft marshmallow treats check in at 93% sugar

#4. Two-Way Tie: Nerds

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 93%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 14g

Calories: 60

Eating Nerds may make you feel smart, but at 93% sugar content, we beg to differ!

#4. Two-Way Tie: Everlasting Gobstopper

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 93%

Weight: 15g

Sugar: 14g

Calories: 60

Famous for their fruity flavors and perpetual pleasure, Willy Wonka's Everlasting Gobstoppers have 93% sugar in every handful.

#3. Pixy Stix

Maker: Nestle

Sugar Content: 94%

Weight: 16g

Sugar: 15g

Calories: 60

With rich sugar cascading from seemingly bottomless paper straws, Pixy Stix surprisingly come in under the 100% mark for sugar content.

#2. Trader Joe's Organic Pops

Maker: Trader Joe's

Sugar Content: 100%

Weight: 17g

Sugar: 17g

Calories: 70

 

These lollipops may have been grown with organic farming practices, but they are still 100% pure sugar. 

#1. Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy

Maker: Tootsie Roll

Sugar Content: 100%

Weight: 40g

Sugar: 40g

Calories: 150

Cotton candy, the fluffy staple of carnivals around the world, is our frontrunner with 100% sugar content.

Trending Now